A Place-Based Approach to Population Sustainability: Internal Migration in Rural Scotland

David McCollum , University of St Andrews

Population sustainability is a prevalent yet nebulous concept within academic and policy debates surrounding the nature and consequences of demographic and economic change. This research seeks to add nuance to understandings of population sustainability in ageing societies. The fiscal challenges posed by population ageing mean that more and more states are implementing specific policies in response to it, with limited degrees of success thus far. This investigation examines place-based understandings of population sustainability on the part of local stakeholders in rural Scotland, a country facing significant demographic challenges and which is enacting policy measures specifically aimed at promoting population sustainability. Specifically, the potential role of internal migration in exacerbating or easing concerns around population sustainability is considered. The findings suggest that the on-the-ground realities of population sustainability are nuanced and complex. Paucities in the supply of housing are a particular challenge, as are significant inequalities in purchasing power within rural housing markets. Changes in residential preferences associated with the covid-19 pandemic have accelerated some of these issues. As such, there is scope for greater attention to the diversity and complexities of population and economic change at the sub-national scale in broader academic conceptualisations of and policy responses to the increasingly pressing issue of population sustainability.

See extended abstract

 Presented in Session 7. Internal Migration and Urbanization